These are all general use, so either would work. I’ve tried all 3 and there’s very little difference. I generally buy Nishiki.
Familiar-Ad3982
I have only tried Botan and it is good.The other two I wouldn’t hesitate trying either. Any Calrose I have tried seems to be good for everything.
Familiar-Ad3982
The Shirakiku is the only one there not pre-washed. The other two are no rinse.
OneLifeJapan
I don’t know a whole lot about those brands, other than I have heard of Nishiki and Botan. For some reason I think Botan is cheaper? But it really matters more how you cook it. Lower quality rice cooked well can be better than high quality rice cooked poorly.
I know it sounds strange to say how you cook it, becuase just put it in a rice cooker and push the button, right? But actually you should do some searching go down the rice cooking rabbit hole when you have time, so I would get the most affordable, and focus on cooking technique. Once you hit the limit on that, start worry more about the brand of rice.
halfstack
:: looks at bags in pantry :: Yes.
As another poster has said, I’ve tried all three and they’re fairly similar to each other – IIRC they’re all US-grown Calrose variety. They’re likely around the same price point as well. Where you notice differences is when you get into more expensive specialty rice (eg, koshihikari) or brown rice/blends.
InfiniteCosmic5
Nishiki.
Though my recommendation will always be Koshihikari
External_Two2928
Japanese-American and my family has always gotten shirakiku, i started getting Nishiki bc it’s at more stores and easier to get
Mister_Pibbs
I’ve always been a nishiki fan
killer_sheltie
Whichever is cheaper
viszlat
I literally cannot taste the difference between these three.
11 Comments
Nishiki
These are all general use, so either would work. I’ve tried all 3 and there’s very little difference. I generally buy Nishiki.
I have only tried Botan and it is good.The other two I wouldn’t hesitate trying either. Any Calrose I have tried seems to be good for everything.
The Shirakiku is the only one there not pre-washed. The other two are no rinse.
I don’t know a whole lot about those brands, other than I have heard of Nishiki and Botan. For some reason I think Botan is cheaper? But it really matters more how you cook it. Lower quality rice cooked well can be better than high quality rice cooked poorly.
I know it sounds strange to say how you cook it, becuase just put it in a rice cooker and push the button, right? But actually you should do some searching go down the rice cooking rabbit hole when you have time, so I would get the most affordable, and focus on cooking technique. Once you hit the limit on that, start worry more about the brand of rice.
:: looks at bags in pantry :: Yes.
As another poster has said, I’ve tried all three and they’re fairly similar to each other – IIRC they’re all US-grown Calrose variety. They’re likely around the same price point as well. Where you notice differences is when you get into more expensive specialty rice (eg, koshihikari) or brown rice/blends.
Nishiki.
Though my recommendation will always be Koshihikari
Japanese-American and my family has always gotten shirakiku, i started getting Nishiki bc it’s at more stores and easier to get
I’ve always been a nishiki fan
Whichever is cheaper
I literally cannot taste the difference between these three.