

Help me decide. Genuinely love both of these cars at face value. Will be going to test drive them hopefully this weekend. Pros and Cons to each. Looking for something small and fun for my off days (have a beater SUV for work). Thanks in advance!
by Johnny-Five0

9 Comments
Only test drove the BRZ but I found the ND to be much more fun on the street and a better value…I bought one
86. Better looking, similar feel to the miata and more room for practical reasons.
Think you’ll definitely come to a decision post test drive, but just keep in mind the GT86 can be a PITA with maintenance.
Older gens kinda plagued with minor oil leaks, changing something simple as spark plugs can become a huge task just cause of boxer layout.
both
I used to have a GT86 and I miss it so much
If I was going to get an MX5, I’d go with the RF, but any of the three will make you very happy
ND. Lighter, convertible, easier/cheaper maintenance, more reliable, more fun.
I’m bias as I’ve owned an NB mx5 and only test driven a GT86 in the past.
The ability to go convertible and cruise around with the top down is honestly such a game changer imo, so enjoyable.
86. Better base car. Better supported mods wise. More sorted car.
You have to drop be both as they are both great cars. I preferred the MX-5 RF but I did not need any extra space for storage. The gearbox is great in the Mazda.