I’ve always wondered how rotten tomatoes for roller coasters would work, so here’s my take on it.

Footage Credit:
ElToroRyan
https://www.youtube.com/c/ElToroRyan
Gotcha Thrills
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCbH-FUIekBZB_79PKEQc2-A
Attraction Source
https://www.youtube.com/c/AttractionSource
Pleasure Beach Experience
https://www.youtube.com/c/ClubPBE
David Hahner
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCsmxF9MJgdeVAq6cVrPve9A
James C
https://www.youtube.com/user/biggdave104
JUSTICE LEAGUE: Battle For Metropolis Expert
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCi23AguRBfY-28-Xkb2NT-Q
Sean Flaharty
https://www.youtube.com/user/SeanFlaharty

Timestamps:
0:00 Intro
1:30 Batman the Ride (SFGAd)
2:16 Boss
2:44 Harley Quinn Crazy Train
3:16 Incredible Hulk
3:55 Magnum XL-200
4:37 Mind Eraser
5:18 Racer 75
5:44 Raptor
6:17 SooperdooperLooper
7:11 Valravn
7:35 Conclusion

12 Comments

  1. Cool video, I think if this was a complete coaster review website then the critic score would be an enthusiasts perspective and the audience score would be the GP perspective, so like I305 would have an enthusiast/critic score of 95% and a GP score of 45-60%.

  2. ..Magnum XL-200's my favorite!! While other coasters may be 'better' (..Maverick, Steel Vengeance), it's my favorite!!

  3. Do more of these! I'll drop some random names

    – Cedar Creek Mine Ride
    – Nitro
    – Superman: Ultimate Flight (SFGAdv)
    – Mr. Freeze: Reverse Blast
    – Blue Streak
    – Great Bear
    – Fahrenheit
    – Rougarou

  4. I agree with almost all of these, but I would actually give the boss a 9.5. It’s very simple, but one of the most fun I’ve ever ridden. Good vid tho

  5. This is a really great concept. I’ll give scores to the ones I’ve ridden:

    Batman: 78%
    Boss: 72%
    Harley Quinn: 45%
    Hulk: 87%
    Magnum: 75%
    Mind Eraser: 10-30%
    Racer 75: 70%
    Raptor: 85%
    Sooperdooperlooper: 58%
    Valravn: 84%

  6. I love the concept, though the way it's executed in the video is more like an IMDB score, lol.
    But thinking about how general audiences vs. coaster critics perceive coasters is truly fascinating, and I wish there was a good way of obtaining those opinions.

Write A Comment