Japan’s First Switch Modder Court Ruling Ends With A Fraction Of Nintendo’s Full Wrath

Image: Zion Grassl / Nintendo Life

It’s not unusual to see Nintendo track down anyone who messes with its products — be that through mods, emulation, or copyright issues — but the outcome of a recent Japanese court ruling feels like a comparative slapped wrist when compared to some of the wrath we’ve seen from The House of Mario in the past (thanks for the heads up, Automaton).

Back in January 2024, 58-year-old transportation worker Fumihiro Otobe became the first man to be arrested in Japan for selling modified Switch consoles. Otobe admitted to the charges immediately, stating, “I was curious if people would think I was great for selling modified machines”, as police discovered four Switch units with soldered circuit boards during a house search.

The modder was apparently selling these units online with 27 pirated games in tow for 28,000 yen (around £150 / $196). It sounds like a pretty small-scale operation and, judging by the outcome of the court ruling, it seems Nintendo thought similarly.

As reported by the Japanese news outlet NTV News, the country’s first Switch mod case ended in Otobe being handed a 500,000 yen fine (roughly £2,600 / $3,500) and a two-year prison sentence, suspended for three years — meaning he might not end up serving any time at all.

Obviously, nobody would want to have to cough up a fine like that, but compared to some of the numbers we’ve seen from Nintendo in the past, this is small potatoes. As pointed out by PC Gamer, modder Gary Bowser was fined a whopping $14.5 million — a 400,000% increase on Otobe — and sentenced to 30 months in prison back in 2022. Sure, Bowser’s Team Xecuter operation was substantially larger than this Japanese case, but you can only assume that Otobe is feeling relieved he managed to avoid quite as heavy a blow.

What do you make of the outcome of Japan’s first Switch modding arrest? Let us know in the comments.

[source automaton-media.com, via news.ntv.co.jp]

See Also

Jim came to Nintendo Life in 2022 and, despite his insistence that The Minish Cap is the best Zelda game and his unwavering love for the Star Wars prequels (yes, really), he has continued to write news and features on the site ever since.